email us610-331-0013
Back to Manual

Why Profit % Sometimes Shows a *

When you run the Calculate Inventory Total tool (steps just below — it totals your wholesale cost, retail value, and profit), you may notice that a few items show a * in the Profit % column instead of a number — while every other column for that item looks normal.

How to get here:

  1. Go to the main screen of TORO.
  2. On the side bar, select the Admin menu item.
  3. Select the Dashboard menu item. (Need help with this part?)
  4. On the side bar of the Dashboard, select Inventory.
  5. Select the Calculate Inventory Total tile.

You should now see a window called Calculate Inventory Total.

That * is not an error. It means one simple thing: this item has a $0 cost, so its markup percentage can't be expressed as a meaningful number. That happens either because the item came in free (a vendor freebie, a promo, a sample) or because a wholesale cost was never entered.

The Short Version

  • Profit Margin answers: "Of the sale price, how much is profit?" It can never go above 100%.
  • Profit % (markup) answers: "How many times over my cost am I selling this for?" It's your profit divided by your cost — and when the cost is $0, dividing by (almost) nothing produces a huge, meaningless number.

Rather than show you a wild figure like 204,600% (or an infinity symbol), TORO shows a * — a clean signal that markup simply doesn't apply to a $0-cost item.

A Real Example

A store owner asked us about a box of Macanudo Emissary Toro:

  • Cost per item: $0.00 (no wholesale cost was ever entered)
  • Retail: $20.47 each
  • Profit %: it was showing 204,600%

Here's what happened. Because the cost was $0, the only thing left on the "cost" side of the math was 16 cents of special tax. Dividing the whole $327 of profit by those few cents gives you 2,046 times over — hence 204,600%. Meanwhile the Profit Margin for the same item read 100%, because if your cost is zero, then 100% of the sale price is profit. Both numbers are technically correct; the markup one is just useless when there's no real cost behind it.

That item is exactly the kind of row that now shows a *.

Why Profit % Can't Be "Capped" at 100%

It's tempting to think the percentage should just stop at 100%, the way Profit Margin does. But markup legitimately goes past 100% all the time:

  • Buy a cigar for $5, sell it for $10 → that's a 100% markup.
  • Buy it for $5, sell it for $15 → that's a 200% markup.
  • Buy it for $5, sell it for $20 → that's a 300% markup.

None of those are wrong, so capping the number would hide honest information. The only time the figure becomes meaningless is when there's no cost at all to measure against — and that's the case the * flags for you.

What to Do About It

First, the good news: the rest of that item's numbers are still correct. Profit $ and Profit Margin are accurate — only the markup % is undefined, because there's no cost to divide by.

Then it depends on why the cost is $0:

  • The item really was free (a vendor freebie, promo, or sample) — then $0 is the correct cost and there's nothing to fix. The * is just the honest way to show that markup doesn't apply. Leave it as-is.
  • The cost was simply never entered — open the item, enter its wholesale cost (what you pay your vendor per stick or per box), and re-run the calculation. The * will turn into a normal percentage and your Wholesale Cost / Profit totals will get more accurate too.

The Takeaway

The * is a quick way to spot every $0-cost item in your inventory. Sort the Profit % column and the starred items group together at the end, and the What does * mean? button on the screen brings you back to this page, so you can tell at a glance which ones are genuinely free and which ones are just missing a cost you meant to enter.